Story Written by: Christopher Simmons @ CHSAANow.com
AURORA — Idalia, last year's 6-man state semifinalist, is off to a strong start in 2025 with a 4-0 record behind a physical run game and stingy defense.
For his efforts, Toby Kechter has been recognized as CHSAA's Broncos Tackle High School Coach of the Week.
Throughout the season, there will be a weekly Broncos Coach of the Week for flag and tackle and every nominee will be recognized on-field at a Broncos home game.
Interview with Toby Kechter
What's the most rewarding part of coaching, especially in a small-school setting like Idalia?
TK: I coach junior high, JV, and varsity alongside my two assistants. We do it all together. The best part is being an example for these young men, not just as athletes but as people. We try to teach them how to be good teammates, friends, sons, and eventually fathers. The group we have right now is a high-character bunch. They hold themselves accountable, and sometimes I feel like they could run practice without me. Seeing that responsibility and maturity is really rewarding.
How would you describe your coaching style, and what shaped the way you lead?
TK: A lot of my peers say I'm "old school," and I take that as a compliment. Discipline and doing things the right way matter to me. For example, we don't allow cursing in practice — if it happens, there are consequences. I tell the kids to show character, even when they're frustrated or hurt. At the same time, I want them to enjoy the game. We have fun when it's appropriate, but when the first drill starts, it's time to work. So I'd say I'm a mix: firm on discipline, but also a players' coach who lets them enjoy the process.
What challenges come with building a program in rural northeastern Colorado?
TK: Honestly, it's more of an advantage. Most of our kids grow up working on farms and ranches. They're feeding animals before school, running equipment after practice, and putting in long hours. That agricultural background teaches them toughness and a strong work ethic, which carries over to football.
At a school like Idalia, where most kids are multi-sport athletes, how does the tight-knit environment shape your program's culture?
TK: It's huge. These kids have been together since preschool, and their families all know each other. That bond creates accountability and trust. They're not just teammates; they're lifelong friends, and that makes the culture really strong.
Last season you went 10-3 and made the state semifinals. What made that group special, and how have you carried that momentum into this year?
TK: We were young and inexperienced, but they were tough and got better every week. In the semifinals, we had the lead with 40 seconds left before losing to the eventual state champion. That loss has motivated this team all offseason. They've worked even harder because they know how close they were, and they want to finish the job this year.
Who are the key leaders on this year's roster, and has anyone surprised you by stepping up?
TK: We only have three seniors, but they're selfless kids who lead by example. They don't act like they're above the freshmen—they just do what's right. We also have strong underclassmen leaders like our quarterback/running back Broderick Kite, my son Gabe, and our center Jaasiel Eatrada. Holden Soehner is another one who really stepped up; he added 25 pounds of muscle this summer and earned a starting spot. It takes the whole team, and the leadership is contagious.
Idalia is known for its tough defense and run game. This season you're averaging 265 rushing yards per game while giving up just 12.5 points. How do you instill that mindset?
TK: Even in 6-man, where a lot of teams like to spread it out and throw, we line up and run right at you. We believe physicality is the most important part of football. Usually, the most physical team wins. That mindset applies on both sides of the ball — you can't be physical on defense if you're not on offense. Our kids know their roles, especially with blocking, and we take pride in that.
Looking ahead, what kind of legacy do you hope Idalia football leaves?
TK: More than wins, I want these young men to grow into tough, hardworking people who know how to be good teammates, friends, sons, and eventually fathers. Football teaches that hard work can overcome anything, and if they carry that lesson into life, they'll be successful no matter what they do.
